January 1, 2024
The travails of the first mollusk on the moon. Gail the snail stands out from the rest, as the bright color-block art makes clear. Unlike the other identical snails, Gail has a spotted shell, her body is dark, her eyes are red-rimmed, and her mouth is a tiny expressive curve. "She sets her stalks on stuff that's big," her ambitions represented by her "Gail Was Here!" flag. She perseveres through challenges--making her way up hills and through rain--and uncertainty. She arrives at Space-Camp, studies diligently, and passes a "SPACE-FIT TEST." Finally, climbing the ladder into a standard-issue spaceship, she slips and falls. Upside down on her shell, she replays her critics' comments ("Give up! Stay safe"), but her heart tells her to go on, so she does. After her triumph, sporting flashy red eyeglasses, she hits the lecture circuit with a lesson: "If you've tried, you cannot fail." It's a well-meaning conclusion that might discourage kids who encounter failure when trying something new; after all, grit alone is no guarantee of success. And conversely, Gail's final advice--"Believe you can...and then you will"--glosses over all the effort she expended along the way. These promises of assured achievement ring false. An amusing but oversold endorsement of persistence. (Picture book. 4-8)
COPYRIGHT(2024) Kirkus Reviews, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.